Giurina v Greater Geelong City Council: MBS emergency orders

 

Giurina v Greater Geelong City Council [No 2] [2026] VSC 646, handed down on 6 October 2026, is a useful reminder for municipal building surveyors.

The facts

The property was a derelict deceased estate. The porch, chimney and front fence risked collapse, and asbestos cement fragments lay on the lawn. After earlier requests to the executor went unanswered, the MBS made a second emergency order under s 102 of the Building Act 1993 (Vic) and arranged demolition and safety works. The executor sued for trespass.

The decision

Council conceded the order had not been served in a way permitted by s 236. Gray J held that entry was lawful under s 228J, which applies where public safety is at risk or an emergency order applies to the land. The works were different. Section 121 allows an MBS to cause work to be done only if an owner "fails" to carry it out. That requires service of the order and expiry of the compliance period, which can be very short in an urgent case but cannot be nil ([108] to [113]). The works were therefore a trespass. Council had borne the cost of making the property safe, so the executor suffered no loss and received $1 in nominal damages.

Two further points

At [106], the Court identified an alternative. Where urgent works are needed and the owner cannot immediately be contacted, s 122 allows the Minister, on a reasonable belief of immediate danger to life or property, to require the MBS to "take any necessary action". At [40], the Court confirmed that although the property stayed registered in the deceased's name, it vested in the executor on probate under s 13 of the Administration and Probate Act 1958 (Vic).

Practical points for MBSs

For MBSs, the lessons are practical. Identify the correct owner, and for a deceased estate obtain probate or letters of administration and name the executor in their representative capacity. Serve the order by a s 236 method and keep admissible proof of service, since the process server's affidavit here was excluded as hearsay. Gray J doubted that s 236 is exhaustive, but did not decide the point, so do not rely on other methods. State a reasonable compliance time and let it expire before relying on s 121. Where danger is immediate and the owner cannot be reached, consider a direction under s 122, because urgency alone does not dispense with the s 121 prerequisites.

Conclusion

Giurina shows that an MBS's powers work in sequence: entry under s 228J was lawful, but the works under s 121 were not, because the owner had not been served and had no chance to "fail" to comply.

 

To learn more about any of the matters discussed here, or if you require legal assistance, please contact Chris Moshidis, Director and Principal Lawyer on +61 3 9521 7956 or chris@urbanlawyers.com.au.